Why This Was the Best Islay Whisky I Tasted in 2026

Every year a handful of drams refuse to leave you alone. You finish the glass, you get on with your life, and three days later you are still thinking about it. This is that bottle. It was a 6 year old from the Islay. And you need to know about it.

My story starts back in 2019. In February, the whisky was distilled. Ironically, I was walking around the new distillery just 3 months later. Already, so close, yet so far.

So what are we talking about?

  • Ardnahoe, 6 years old
  • Bourbon barrels
  • 55% ABV, non-chill-filtered, no colouring added
  • 762 bottles, bottled in August 2025
  • A private bottling for Roy Duff and the Aqvavitae community

BTW, Roy considers 55 his lucky number. Certainly, 55% proved to be correct in this case.

Islay’s new kid, built the old-fashioned way

Ardnahoe opened in 2019 as Islay’s ninth working distillery, and the first new one on the island since Kilchoman in 2005. It was built by the Laing family of Hunter Laing, the Glasgow independent bottlers: Stewart Laing and his sons Andrew and Scott. Jim McEwan, the man behind the Bruichladdich revival, came out of retirement to help set it up.

There are Oregon pine washbacks and long, slow fermentations. There are two lantern-shaped stills with what are said to be the longest lyne arms in Scotland, at 7.5 metres. And there are worm tubs, the only ones on Islay. The water comes from Loch Ardnahoe, arguably the deepest loch on the island.

The setting is near idyllic. The stills stand in front of tall windows, and behind them, across the Sound of Islay, sit the Paps of Jura. The view is so central to the place that it appears on the distillery’s logo.

Why this bottling works

Long lyne arms tend to push a spirit towards lightness, because more of the heavy vapour falls back into the still before it escapes. Worm tubs tend to push the other way: the spirit condenses slowly with less copper contact, and keeps more weight and texture. Ardnahoe is unusual that it combines both.

On the evidence of this bottle, the approach paid off. The nose is all lift and freshness. The palate has real body. That is the design doing exactly what it said on the tin.

Tasting notes

Ardnahoe 6 YO 55% ABV

Nose: Rich. Floral, with apple and light citrus.

Palate: Delicious. Slightly sweet, with plums, sugared barley and apple tart. Definitely, worm tub texture.

Finish: Do not go looking for the end of it, because you will not find it. Slow, heart-warming, and it simply keeps going.

Would I buy it again?

Without hesitation. The catch is that I cannot, and I have just finished my bottle. It was a one-off of 762 bottles. If you do happen to see one, do not dither.

What comes next

Ardnahoe now has a cask strength series in its own core range. Roy recently tried Batch 3, a six year old from first-fill bourbon barrels at 60.4%, and very clearly peated. He was clearly impressed, and it is firmly on my list.

Ardnahoe has a rapidly growing reputation in the whisky geek community. And this bottle is all the evidence you need to prove that.

Slàinte!

Share:

More Posts